This is how it goes:
I have two brothers, Ben and Charles (whom I call Chuck).
Their lives has often defined mine.
But that's changed.
I've always carried a bitterness towards Ben.
Oldest child, magnet schools, Deerfield, Harvard grad, happily married, two kids.
Sounds perfect on paper, no?
For the longest time, I resented the fact that I had to "live up" to him.
When my family moved to Seattle to help him out with his new family, I learned he was bitter and disconnected from our family. Not quite perfect as he seemed.
When the living circumstances didn't work out, I only came to resent him more for what he said to my mother, and for the year at Deerfield I was being robbed of. He was the brother who had gone away when I was a year old, and yet he he had demanded of me sacrifice.
Then you have Chuck.
Chuck, whose kind face towered over me in all my memories. Chuck, who first handed me pen and paper to express myself.
He was the failure, by book definition.
In college, he married his girlfriend of 4 years and got a job. Slowly, he stopped taking classes until he dropped out. He never went back.
6 years later, he found himself divorced, jobless, and a bit lost.
My two brothers, one failed by the book definition, the other failed by that Filipino rationale: family first.
And here I was, last child, only daughter, American-born, brought into the world just in time to witness the beginning of my brothers' growing pains.
Growing up, life was one big lecture: Where my brothers went wrong, and what I needed to do.
It was never said, always implied, but it was plain to see.
On my shoulders, I carried my family's "American dream."
Somehow, I should go to Deerfield, become successful, but still be the good Filipino daughter I ought to be, succeeding where both brothers had failed.
The other day, I had a long conversation with Chuck and I found out Ben was even
less perfect than I had perceived. Chuck described one of our brother's fatal flaws as his lack of individual personality. My parents had a very specific idea of what they wanted him to be. After an embarrassing propaganda incident in middle school, he started becoming "the rebel", a new identity. Deerfield, with its upper-crust society, only seemed to help my brother into creating a new identity for himself. I do remember my father once asking him, "Do you really think you're a true American now? Ha!" The years went on, and my brother partied with his fraternity in college. At the end, he was only the identity he chose for himself.
As Chuck puts it, sort of like Gatsby.
I asked Chuck, "What
is it Mama and Papa want me to be?"
He told me,
"Don't get confused into thinking they want you to be a lawyer or a doctor, kid. It took me a long time to figure out, but they just want us to have happy, honest lives. They don't want us to struggle anymore. That's all."
It sounds like something out of Hallmark card; and it seems so apparent it's silly to record. But after spending my life under the weight of my American dream-complex, it astounded me.
Now, one of the centers of my whirling pool of teenage angst has been effaced from existence.
My "life is shitty" story has been made non-existent.
And now there's this gaping hole.
Ellie suggested that maybe, the problem was that I had distorted my view of the American dream. Wasn't it always that: to work hard and earn your due. Enjoy the fruits of your labor, which no one had the right to take away?
Does this completely change me, and my work ethic? Of course not.
I wanted great things for myself, regardless.
But now I can drop the shackles from my wrists, and I know for sure now:
I'm doing all of this because
I chose it.